Heck yeah. I loved Andrew Garfield Spider-Man. He was perfect for the moves, quips, webshooter... pretty much everything.
For Peter Parker, on the other hand...
*ahem* *cough* not Peter *cough cough*
He played the perfect awkward yet not disturbingly creepy teenager that Macguire never seemed to grab on to. Of the two Parker's I have to say he handled the general psyche of the comic book character a lot better. Peter has the worst luck and probably some of the most horrible things happen to him in the comic-verse to the point where he almost remains a troubled teenager in a man's body his whole life. I feel like Andrew got that across perfectly and dare I say it... he was all around the Superior Spider-Man.